Archive for the ‘broken web sites’ Category

“Create a signature that automatically added to your emails”

Tuesday, February 19th, 2008

I’m not sure how many times I’ve looked at this page without seeing this typo:

Yahoo typo error

I assume that:

“Create a signature that automatically added to your emails”

is suppose to read:

“Create a signature that is automatically added to your emails”

I always find it surprising to find typos on a major site like Yahoo.

A rule for user interaction: keep debugging information out of error messages

Sunday, February 10th, 2008

Yet another example of bad web programming. I was researching the subject of cancer and followed a link on a government site that gets me to this page:

Error message on government site: debugging information should be kept off of live sites

I think its fine to print debugging information to the screen when a website is under development, but on a live site, I think the error messages should try to be more helpful. Perhaps the error message can suggest the average speed it takes the site’s sysadmins to fix problems of this time. Or the error message can suggest that the visitor go get the page out of the Google cache. Even the cutesy error message that Stikipad used was more reassuring than this.

Netflix error: why allow a date that is not allowed?

Sunday, February 10th, 2008

Back on September 24th, I decided to put my Netflix account on hold. I knew I was facing a stretch of time when I was going to be too busy to watch movies. Apparently Netflix only allows you to put your account on hold for 90 days. Nevertheless, the form that I was presented with allowed me to choose any date in December, so I chose December 31st, as you can see here:

Netflix error: the form that allows forbidden dates to be choosen

Upon submitting the form, I got the following error message:

Netflix error: why do they allow users to choose dates that are in fact not allowed by their policies?

This is, of course, an example of bad user interface design. They should not allow me to choose a date which they themselves forbid. It is confusing that their form should offer a date which is, in fact, not allowed.

There are reasons to be wary of online services

Sunday, February 3rd, 2008

Shelley Powers once wrote that she wouldn’t use an online service unless she was sure of the exit route:

I won’t use a hosted web service like Typepad or weblogs.com. It’s too easy for them to decide that you’re ‘violating’ terms of service, and next thing you know, all your weblog entries are gone. I saw this with wordpress.com in the recent events that caused so much discussion: in fact, I would strongly recommend against using wordpress.com because of this–the service is too easily influenced by public opinion.

I don’t use either my Yahoo or Gmail mail accounts. Regardless of whether I can get a copy of my email locally, if I decide to not use either account I have no way of ‘redirecting’ email addresses from either of these to the email address I want to use. (Or if there is a way, I’m not aware of it.) Getting a copy of my data is not an exit strategy–it’s an export strategy. An exit strategy is one where you can blow off the service and not suffer long-term consequences. A ‘bad’ email address is definitely a long-term consequence*.

A few months ago we started using Stikipad to get ourselves organized. We started using the site under conditions that were close to an emergency - we had a web site that was past its deadline, and we were trying to regain control over a situation that had become chaotic. We began to post bug reports and notes to ourselves. Stikipad was useful to us as an easy-to-use online notepad, which we could use informally. It helped that it also had certain wiki features - it kept track of who made each edit, and it allowed us to revert changes when we made mistakes in editing.

Since then, we’ve started listing all the hours that we work on there. This data is vital for when we send out invoices to our clients. Also, all of the long, complicated to-do lists, for each project we’ve been working on, are all on there. We did not realize how important the site had become to us - we’d set up a quick, free account as a simple way to organize one project, but our use of Stikipad has grown so that lately it has been central to the way we schedule our time.

For the last three days, when we go to the site, the only thing we get is this error page:

Error message on Stikipad

The whole entire site has been down. You could not start a new account, nor reach any of the pages on our account, nor even reach the “Support” page. We all kept trying, at different times during Friday, Saturday and Sunday. There was no way into the site.

The site just came back to life tonight. But we are planning on giving it up. We feel we can’t trust it anymore. There has been no word on the Stikipad blog about what just happened. Their silence does not inspire confidence in us.

Stikipad does have an export option, which we could use religiously to keep our data safe. I blame myself for not already automating a daily download of this data. I’m fixing this particular oversight tonight. All the same, Stikipad can’t value our most vital data to the same extent we can, so it is perhaps best if we keep that data on our own server, and make the multiple backups of that data which we feel is needed.

Microsoft’s website is broken

Monday, October 1st, 2007

 Yes, that is a broken image link on the Microsoft website (I hit refresh a few times and it was still there). Ironically, the page is talking about a new technique for debugging.

Error on the Microsoft page about KISS debugging

Part of what is becoming a continuing series on the subject of broken web pages.

Old Navy website is broken too

Sunday, September 30th, 2007

Well, maybe “broken” is too strong a word. The CSS failed to load. Which happens sometimes. Which is part of why semantic markup is important. How much does the user experience survive the lack of style sheets? This from the front page of Old Navy:

oldnavybroken.jpg

Just curious, but does anyone know some common reasons why the CSS files might fail to load?

Also curious about the marketing. The front page of the site is aimed entirely at women. Do women buy clothes online more than men?

SprintPCS has a broken website (Updated)

Friday, September 14th, 2007

Yet another story about a badly programmed website, with really bad error messages.

I went to pay my monthly cell phone bill. Just last month, SprintPCS instituted a new policy, requiring stricter passwords with more letters and numbers in them. So I was forced to change my password. Perhaps I was also in a hurry, as I did not write it down in the usual place.

Today, unable to remember the new password, I clicked the link they offer for “Forgot your password?” I came to the screen you see in the first image.

this is the form on SprintPcs.com where I request my password

I typed in my “username”, which is simply my telephone number. When I hit the submit button, I got, in response, a blank white page with the text “Error: 500″. That’s it. Nothing else. Just that text on a blank white page. You can see it in this second image:

This is the error message I got from SprintPCS. Not very helpful, is it?
I offer this anecodote as one more small piece of evidence for the case that most web sites are horribly programmed and poorly tested. I don’t mean to pick on SprintPCS, since there are many sites that are just as bad, but this just happens to be the broken website that I interacted with today.

Mind you, the above incident happened this morning, around 11 AM, and now it is 11 PM. I just went back to get screenshots. Twelve hours later, the problem is still there.

I sent SprintPCS an email about this. I have not yet heard back from them. I’ll update this post if I do hear from them.

UPDATE: wonderful response time. I just got this, on the 17th. The irony:

Date: Mon, 17 Sep 2007 14:08:18 -0500 [02:08:18 PM CDT]

From: Sprint Customer Solutions <ecare@cc.sprintpcs.com>

To: LAWRENCE@KRUBNER.COM

Subject: Re: Subject: ID # 20070914212929 (KMM38317571I123L0KM)

Hello Lawrence Krubner,

Thank you for contacting Sprint.

A ticket has been submitted in reference to the difficulty you are experiencing logging into your account online at Sprint.com. The ticket number is 16880851.

A follow-up call will be made to you within 36 business hours.

Thank you again for contacting Sprint. We appreciate your business.

Mary O.
E-Care
Sprint
“Where our customers come first!”

Refer someone to Sprint and get $25.

So after 3 days, they send me an email in which they promise to contact me within 3 days. Then they close with “Where our customers come first!” Hate to think how we’d be treated if we came second.